In this paper, we consider 1D agent-based and kinetic models of aggregation with reversals. In particular, we fit a Gamma distribution to represent the run times in myxobacteria and analyze numerically the importance of non-exponential reversal times. We demonstrate that non-exponential reversal times aid aggregation and result in tighter aggregates. We compare and contrast the behavior of agent-based and kinetic models, and also consider kinetic models with aggregation driven by chemotaxis. Thus, incorporating non-exponential reversal times into models of aggregation can be particularly important for reproducing experimental data, such as aggregate persistence and dispersal.