Post-translational modifications (PTMs) of histones regulate chromatin structure and function. Because nucleosomes contain two copies each of the four core histones, the establishment of different PTMs on individual 'sister' histones in the same nucleosomal context, i.e. asymmetric histone PTMs, are difficult to analyze. Here, we generated differentially isotope-labeled nucleosomes to study asymmetric histone modification crosstalk by time-resolved NMR spectroscopy. Specifically, we delineate mechanistic insights into nucleosomal histone H3 modification reactions in cis and in trans, hence within individual H3 copies, or between them. We validated our approach using the H3S10phK14ac crosstalk mechanism, mediated by Gcn5 acetyltransferase. Moreover, phosphorylation assays on methylated substrates identified Haspin kinase able under certain conditions to produce nucleosomes decorated asymmetrically with two distinct types of PTMs. PTMs of histones work in concert through the formation of combinatorial patterns or histone codes to regulate a plethora of fundamental biological processes, including transcription, replication, recombination and DNA repair. [1,2] Most of these PTMs occur in the unstructured N-or C-terminal tails of core histones and at closely spaced modification sites, giving rise to functional networks of reciprocal PTM crosstalk. [3] Although a few PTMs are deposited on free histone substrates, the vast majority are placed on nucleosomeincorporated histones. The nucleosome is a symmetric structure consisting of ~147bp of DNA wrapped around a histone octamer made up of two copies each of the four-core histones. [4] Historically, and because of the inherent symmetry of the nucleosomal architecture, histone PTMs were thought to exclusively occur in a symmetrical fashion, with both copies of each of the core histones modified in exactly the same manner. This notion was recently challenged by two studies demonstrating the mechanistic basis for establishing asymmetric histone H3 phosphorylations in vitro by certain kinases, [5] and the existence of asymmetrically methylated nucleosomes in embryonic stem cells, fibroblasts and cancer cells.
Abstract[6] As such, asymmetrically modified nucleosomes represent a novel concept in chromatin biology and their existence raises important biological questions with regard to their establishment and crosstalk in cis, i.e. within individual histone tails, and in trans, i.e.between the two copies of sister histones that this asymmetry might impose on the propagation of histone marks.Most analytical methods to investigate histone PTMs on nucleosomal substrates fall short in verifying the copy-specific origin of the detected modifications. By proteolytically processing modified nucleosomes for mass spectrometry analysis, for example, individual histone tails are cleaved off from core particles and detected in mixtures of modified peptides, which effectively 'erases' all information about whether they originated from the same, or from different nucleosomes. To pre...