“Censorship”, early childhood research quarterly and qualitative research: Not so much aced out as an own goal?

Abstract

As its starting point, this article investigates claims published in Qualitative Inquiry by Ceglowski, Bacigalupa, and Peck (2011) that Early Childhood Research Quarterly censored qualitative research. Unfortunately they assert rather than demonstrate political bias against qualitative research, fail to show that its publication in Early Childhood Research Quarterly has actually declined and ignore alternate hypotheses compatible with their data. After breaking their argument into parts, I find their censorship claims completely unsupported by evidence. However, this article has two larger aims. The first is to show how mistaking hypotheses for evidence, arguing unconvincingly from quantitative data, and failing to consider alternative interpretations of evidence weaken qualitative research, lowering its credibility within social science.The second is to consider the wider academic ramifications of publishing a peerreviewed journal article that totally fails to support its claims. Based on these concerns, the article offers some practical advice to avoid the negative outcomes demonstrated by the publication of Ceglowski, Bacigalupa, and Peck and considers the scientific implications of this rebuttal to their claims having been rejected previously by Qualitative Inquiry.

Australian Research in Early Childhood Education and Care: Insights Into the Actual; Imagining the Possible

“…For example, authors who specialize in qualitative methodologies have opined that their academic peers, journal editors, and policymakers overlook the importance and legitimacy of their research studies (Ceglowski et al, 2011; Freeman et al, 2007; Schuermans, 2013; Tracy, 2010) in favor of objective, quantitative, and positivist/postpositivist research approaches (Morse, 2015). Such vituperations (Ceglowski et al, 2011; Chattoe-Brown, 2015; Winsler, 2015) are pertinent in understanding the state of ECEC research in Australia.…”