Centralization and Decentralization in Administration and Politics: Assessing Territorial Dimensions of Authority and Power

Abstract

Throughout the world, diverse countries are implementing programs of decentralization as a means of promoting both democratic and developmental objectives. Unfortunately, however, scholarship has yet to offer a comprehensive framework within which to assess and reform central-local relations. This article seeks to overcome the "division of labor" that has long separated analyses of administrative and political structures, and to provide stronger conceptual vocabulary for describing and analyzing the complexities of centralization and decentralization in both administration and politics. After developing two distinct continua of administrative and political centralization/decentralization, the paper then combines them in a single matrix able to highlight the wide range of strategies and outcomes that emerge from the complex interplay of the two spheres. Depending on where a country lies within the matrix, it is argued, strategies of decentralization may do more harm than good. Strategies of devolution are especially problematic in settings with strong local bosses, and should never be attempted without careful analysis of the preexisting character of central-local ties.

Is Decentralization Leading to "Real" Decision-Making Power for Forest-dependent Communities? Case Studies from Mexico and Brazil

“…This study borrows mostly from the description of power provided by Agrawal and Ribot (1999) as the ability to make decisions about how the forest resource is used, to create rules or modify old ones, and to ensure compliance with them. We also borrow from Hutchcroft (2001) and Uphoff's (1989) descriptions of authority as conferring a formal power role, but specifically use it here to mean authority bestowed by legal decree, without regarding it as having been legitimately conferred by all actors. Within the realm of power and authority, we consider the overall control the community has over the resource, and also distinguish between legally-bestowed, de jure control (authority) and de facto control, which occurs regardless of legal authority.…”

Fit-for-Purpose Institutions? An Evaluation of Biodiversity Conservation in the Agricultural Landscape of the Tasmanian Midlands, Australia

“…Power and authority: Power is exercised when actors pursue values, interests and goals (Gordon, 2009). Authority bestows formal roles and responsibilities on individuals and organizations (Hutchcroft, 2001). Adaptive governance supports greater power sharing and the devolution of power and authority to appropriate levels.…”

Local Authority Empowerment towards Quality Living Environment for Coastal Reclamation Area

“…According to Hutchcroft (2001) [14], the decentralisation involves as much more extensive transfer of decision-making authority and responsibility to the local government units and it is usually involving regions, provinces, and/or municipalities. Hence, this concept of work can be seen as a sharing-power concept.…”