Alumino‐borosilicate glass‐ceramics (GCs) containing alkali (Na), alkaline earth (Ca), rare earth (RE) (one of La … Lu, Y), and transition metals (Zr and Mo) were formulated to test the effects of composition and RE cation size on the crystallization of simulated nuclear waste GCs. Eight‐oxide glasses were formulated in the peraluminous ([Na2Oexcess]=[Na2O]‐[Al2O3]‐[ZrO2]<0) region with 10 mol.% RE2O3 and 15 mol.% B2O3. Glasses were melted and quenched, reheated, and slow‐cooled to promote crystallization, and then characterized using quantitative X‐ray diffraction and electron probe microanalysis. Transition metal phases [powellite (Ca,Na,RE)MoO4 and zirconia (Zr,RE)O2 or zircon (Zr,RE)SiO4] always formed, while borosilicate (RE3BSi2O10) or silicate [oxyapatite (RE,Ca,Na)10Si6O26 or keiviite (RE2Si2O7)] plus borate (REBO3) phases also formed, depending on the size of the RE cation and hence its preferred coordination number. All crystalline phases were found to contain RE elements, and often phases incorporated other cations (Zr, Ca, B) which were not nominally part of their pure stoichiometry. These results suggested that the glass formulation and RE size strongly influenced the RE environment in the glass and hence the crystal phases formed. The formation of RE borosilicate, versus separate RE borate and RE silicate phases, also suggested original differences in the glass structure.