Challenge for Planning by Using Cluster Methodology: The Case Study of the Algarve Region

Abstract

This study analyses the most appropriate methodology to make similarity classifications among the cities of the Algarve (Portugal) according to 105 sustainability indicators monitored with the Observatory of Sustainability of the Algarve Region for Tourism (OBSERVE). The methodology used to establish the similarities was the cluster analysis with 4 different approaches which reduced the dimensions of the data set: total approach, pillar approach, subject area approach, and indicator approach. By combining the approaches, a total of 620 different cluster analyses were performed. The results reflected that the data analysis approaches with less dimensions were those that performed the best groups among cities. In this sense, the approaches with a high number of indicators (e.g., the total or the pillar approach) were characterised by misclassifying cities in more than 30% of the indicators. Thus, the most acceptable cluster analysis approach was that with a low number of indicators. Through this approach, it was possible to make correct groups of the sustainability level of the cities of the Algarve. These results provided an appropriate methodology for the decision-making regarding the sustainability of a region and could be extrapolated to other regions to assess sustainability or environmental indicators.

Analysing natural ventilation to reduce the cooling energy consumption and the fuel poverty of social dwellings in coastal zones

“…To analyse the similarity among the coastal cities, unidimensional cluster analyses were performed [87] . For this purpose, k-means was used; this is an iterative resignation algorithm based on the centroid concept of clusters of observations [88] .…”

Discretization of the Urban and Non-Urban Shape: Unsupervised Machine Learning Techniques for Territorial Planning

“…This value represents the ratio of the total between-groups sum of squares (BSS) to the total sum of squares (TSS). Higher values of BSS/TSS entail a better cluster separation [46]. This procedure was executed for each grid shift, extrapolating, among 88 values (one for every clustering algorithm (11) performed for each grid shift (4), first considering only urbanized and non-urbanized areas, then considering all the main categories), the best ones with the belonging method (Table 1).…”

Sustainable Competitiveness of Tourism in the Algarve Region. Critical Stakeholders’ Perception of the Supply Sector

“…Traditionally, it is the most widely used supervised inductive learning classification technique used in the decision-making process and has the advantage that the connections between nodes can be expressed at the computational level as if-then rules, which facilitates their programming in different programming languages [69]. Due to this aspect, it is possible to establish the relationships between the input and output variables that best group the data set.…”