Challenges for Police Leadership: Identity, Experience, Legitimacy and Direct Entry

Abstract

The police service in England and Wales has developed a new approach to police leadership where individuals from outside of the police service can now enter directly to leadership ranks. Previous research identified that officers place great value on being led by someone who has experience of being a police officer. Adopting a social identity perspective, the current paper reports on quantitative and qualitative data about police officer views on direct entry and existing police leadership captured as part of a wider national survey (N = 12,549) of police officers in England and Wales. The paper identifies the importance that shared identity and credibility play in police follower/leadership relationships. It argues that direct-entry police leaders face credibility issues linked to their lack of shared police identity but also that serving officers perceive existing leaders to be poor because they believe they have forgotten what it is like to be a police officer. This paper develops a new theoretical and empirical approach to police leadership utilizing social and organizational psychology theory and research. The paper suggests that if police leaders understand police identity, then they can create propitious conditions within which police officers will follow their leaders.

Change or be changed: Diagnosing the readiness to change in the Canadian police sector

“…The literature is replete with studies seeking to enhance our understanding of how police agencies can successfully implement change (Carter, 2016). Many authors have catalogued the ‘raft’ of policing reforms introduced over the past century (e.g., Bayley, 2008; Green, 2000; Hoggett et al ., 2013; Mastrofski and Willis, 2010). A number of conclusions can be drawn from this literature regarding planned change within the police sector.…”

“…A number of conclusions can be drawn from this literature regarding planned change within the police sector. First, most police sector change efforts in this sector in North America (Bayley, 2008) and the UK have been ‘driven from the top-down and outside-in’ (Hoggett et al ., 2013: 8). Second, the pace of organisational change within policing appears to be ‘glacial—slow and at times torturous’ (Green, 2000: 309).…”

“…Second, the pace of organisational change within policing appears to be ‘glacial—slow and at times torturous’ (Green, 2000: 309). Third, any change that has occurred has been small and modest (Maguire et al ., 2003; Mastrofski and Willis, 2010) and any significant attempt to reform the police has proved to be contentious and difficult (Hoggett et al ., 2013; Skogan, 2008). Finally, while generalisations are hazardous, our review of the literature suggests that police reform is difficult and risky, and that efforts to implement transformational change within police organisations are likely to either fall short of expectations or fail (Skogan, 2008).…”

Professional Psychological Profile of a Modern Patrol Officer as the Basis of Efficient Official Activities

“…At the same time, some results of previous empirical studies (Bondarenko et al, 2020a;Hoggett et al, 2019;Shvets et al, 2020) show that the level of the psychological readiness of patrol police officers for official activity is often insufficient that leads to the cases of death and injuries of police officers in many countries around the world, violation of human rights and freedoms, abuse of power, and so on. The motivation of the professional choice of police officers, special knowledge and skills, individual qualities do not always meet the requirements of the profession to the officer's personality.…”

Attitude of Young People to the Criminality Problem in Ukrainian Postmodern Society

“…Effective crime counteraction in a society is impossible without taking into account the population's attitude to this problem, its assessment of the police's activities aimed at counteracting such phenomenon (Birzu, 2017;Hoggett et al, 2019;Valieiev, Polyvaniuk et al, 2019;Săraru, 2016). Such knowledge allows drafting adequate policy to counteract crime in the country, improving the forms and methods of the police bodies' work, and conducting the task-oriented cultural and education activities among citizens (Damme, 2017;Kohlström et al, 2017;Morris et al, 2020;Van Dijk, 2015;Yesberg & Bradford, 2019).…”