Challenges of sustainable industrial transformation: Swedish biorefinery development and incumbents in the emerging biofuels industry

Abstract

This paper investigates the transformation challenges related to incumbent industries caused by technology development and industry convergence in the transition to a bioeconomy in the context of Swedish biorefinery development. It involves the emergence of new value chains and several incumbent industries such as the pulp and paper industry, the oil refinery sector, the chemical process industry, and the heat and power sector. In 2019, Sweden had Europe's largest share of biofuels in the transport sector, roughly 20% on an energy basis, and this share has increased by around 300% during the last decade. At the same time, domestic production has stalled, and even though Sweden has beneficial conditions for biofuel production, the share of biofuel that is imported or based on imported feedstock has recently ranged between 85% and 90%. We discuss three transformation challenges: (i) inertia and lack of absorptive capacity creating lock‐in effects at the organizational level; (ii) weak and inefficient actor networks at the industry level; and (iii) contradictory policy instrument mixes and lack of coordination at the government level. The findings underscore the need for policy integration and alignment across various policy domains, and an increased focus on policy mixes that can stimulate the emergence of more disruptive innovations and value chains. There is also a need for industrial initiatives, such as improving absorptive capacity and strengthening actor networks, to help build the value chains needed to realize a sustainable bioeconomy. 2021 The Authors. Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining published by Society of Industrial Chemistry and John Wiley & Sons Ltd

Decarbonizing the pulp and paper industry: A critical and systematic review of sociotechnical developments and policy options

“…For example, in the Swedish PPI, R&D shares of total turnover are traditionally below 1%. The same study notes that investments are often oriented toward improving processes instead of product diversification [356]. Financial barriers also represent the main obstacle to developing biorefineries.…”

Decarbonising Aotearoa New Zealand’s Aviation Sector: hard to abate, but even harder to govern

“…Concerns about the sustainability of feedstocks remain, however, leaving a major question for New Zealand as to the wisdom, timing and structure of investments in wood-based biofuel. The development of domestic biofuel industries is challenging even the most biomasssupportive countries, such as Sweden (Mossberg, Söderholm and Frishammar, 2021). The most viable pathway is to produce biocrude from wood (either waste wood or whole logs), which would likely need to be refined overseas (BioPacific Partners, 2021;Indufor, 2021).…”

To facilitate a fair bioeconomy transition, stronger regional‐level linkages are needed

“…Government support to advance biodiesel may obstruct the market for such value creation, limiting local forward linkages of forest industries. So far, innovations have mostly been incremental, as the incumbent industries prioritize innovations that do not conflict with core skills and practices, whereby more advanced biorefinery trajectories, based on byproducts with favorable sustainability performance, are being forfeited 32 . Despite royalty payments from tree harvesting in Finland, the overall fiscal linkages are weak at the regional level.…”