Challenging Moderate Muslims: Indonesia’s Muslim Schools in the Midst of Religious Conservatism

Abstract

Muslim schools are an important element of education in Indonesia. The school was in place long before Indonesia’s independence in 1945. Schools educate Indonesian Muslim children to understand and practice religion while promoting a sense of nationalism. Thanks to Muslim schools, Indonesian Muslims are recognized as being moderate. Recently, however, the moderate nature of Indonesian Islam is challenged by the spirit of conservative Islam. The question is how Muslim schools play their roles in the discourse of moderate versus conservative Muslims. This study identified five issues that are largely discussed among Indonesian Muslims: Islam and state, Muslims–non Muslims relations, non-mainstream Islam, gender, and media. Knowing that there is a strong relationship between society and education, i.e., religious education, it is important to see the relationship between schools and society including how the current conservative trend in Indonesian Islam is being taught at schools. This study explored how the curriculum of (Islamic) religious education potentially contributes toward the development of Indonesian conservative Muslims and how religious education teachers view sensitive issues concerning conservative Islam. To answer these questions, the analysis of religious education curricula and the interviewing of teachers serve as the primary methods of data collection. Four religious education teachers from different provinces of Indonesia were interviewed to reveal their opinions on various religion-related issues. This paper discusses how Islamic education in Indonesia has been designed to present moderate Islam but, at the same time, faces a number of challenges that try to turn religious education into conservative religious doctrines.

Principals as socio-religious curators: progressive and conservative approaches in Islamic schools

“…On the other hand, some principals' socio-religious leadership curated school cultures that promoted mono-culturalism, pure identities and authoritarianism (Zuhdi, 2018). To provide an example of the latter, one principal spoke of his decision requiring all individuals associated with the school to wear his particular interpretation of Islamically-appropriate clothing – even if they were not Muslim or did not wear such clothing outside of the school.…”

“…Seeking to fill this gap are sekolah Islamic schools, which are modern Islamic schools that use the MoEC's secular curricula and create their own Islamic curricula. Due to their higher tuition costs, sekolah Islamic schools boast modern amenities and focus on instilling practical Islamic values and ethics in students' day-to-day lives (Azra, 2014; Subhan, 2010; Zuhdi, 2018).…”

Preparation of Islamic Religious Education Teachers in Secular Countries: A Study in Austria

“…There is actually no clear demarcation between conservatives and moderates. However, one can generalize that the conservatives tended to be more closed to differences while the moderates tended to be more accepting of differences (Zuhdi, 2018).…”

Kiai in Indonesian Social-Political Changes

“…Together with pesantren, the kiai's efforts to contribute to the space and field of political life by incorporating Islamic values and morality do not stop. Pesantren as the oldest education is used as a means of planting an Islamic value system capable of creating religious individuals in the life of a more religious society with teaching that leads to strengthening religious understanding or tafaqquh fî al-dîn (expertise in religious studies) (Zuhdi, 2018), and kiai. as a leader often has an influence on the socio-political life of the community.…”