Challenging “The Hands of Technology”: An Analysis of Independent Living for People with Intellectual Disabilities

Abstract

Technology has been holding out the promise of facilitating greater autonomy and improving care for people in a situation of dependency. This trend is expected to grow and this is happening precisely at a time of expansion of the so-called Independent Living paradigm. In this context, however, disability activists are generally suspicious of approaches based on being “left” in the hands of technology. They instead advocate for “subordinating hands” to their ability to decide, a principle that stands in tension with the field of intellectual disability, where individuals are perceived as intrinsically unable to make “good decisions”. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to provide insight into the uses and developments of technologies with regard to care and autonomy for people with intellectual disabilities. By ethnographically examining the case of a specific technology; QR (quick response) codes in the context of an independent living service, and in the framework of Science and Technology Studies and Disability Studies, the paper reveals the role and possibilities of care and autonomy technologies for people with intellectual disabilities. Based on these findings, and by thinking from what we could define as “within a sociotechnical assemblage”, this paper aims to rethink the ways in which technologies for independent living can be used in the field.

Ethical and Practical Concerns of Heart Rate Monitoring: Enabling Communication for Patients with Severe Communication Difficulties

“…Thus autonomy hinges on both liberty (freedom from controlling influences), agency (the capacity for intentional action), and understanding (the ability to understand the content and consequences of alternatives) 25 . In the contemporary discourse of disability, as separated into biological impairment, mental incapacity, and social disability [26][27][28] , autonomy extends beyond traditional notions and has been reconceptualized as the capacity to establish meaningful connections and relationships 28 . In this and other relational definitions, autonomy is "distributed agency", meaning it is dispersed among diverse human and non-human actors interconnected at specific times 29,30 .…”

Tensions and Escapes in Independent Living Infrastructures for People With Disabilities Under COVID-19

“…Science and technology studies have shown how the capacity to act depends on heterogeneous networks that allow certain modes of individual agency (Callon, 2008). In the case of AC, this involves the articulation of a set of more or less formal meetings with families and users, the formulation of a personal care plan, the provision of formal and informal meeting spaces, the use of furniture catalogues, certain technologies, and so on (Moyà-Köhler & Domènech, 2021; 2022) that allow the person with learning disabilities to emerge as autonomous in the process of thinking (Law, 1999) and taking decisions. In the case of CL, it entails facilitating a nonhospital space, to develop individualized plans, the promotion of community activities, and the training of assistants in the promotion of independent living.…”