Changes in Soil Phosphorus Fractions and Ecosystem Dynamics across a Long Chronosequence in Hawaii

Abstract

We tested the Walker and Syers (1976) conceptual model of soil development and its ecological implications by analyzing changes in soil P, vegetation, and other ecosystem properties on a soil chronosequence with six sites ranging in age from 300 yr to 4.1 x 106 yr. Climate, dominant vegetation, slope, and parent material of all of the sites were similar. As fractions of total P, the various pools of soil phosphorus behaved very much as predicted by Walker and Syers. HCI—extractable P (presumably primary mineral phosphates) comprised 82% of total P at the 300—yr—old site, and then decreased to 1% at the 20,000—yr—old site. Organic phosphorus increased from the youngest site to a maximum at the 150 000 yr site, and then declined to the 4.1 x 106 yr site. Occluded (residual) P increased steadily with soil age. In contrast to the Walker and Syers model, we found the highest total P at the 150 000—yr—old site, rather than at the onset of soil development, and we found that the non—occluded, inorganic P fraction persisted through to the oldest chronosequence site. Total soil N and C increased substantially from early to middle soil development in parallel with organic P, and then declined through to the oldest site. Readily available soil P, NH4+, and NO3— were measured using anion and cation exchange resin bags. P availability increased and decreased unimodally across the chronosequence. NH4+ and NO3— pools increased through early soil development, but did not systematically decline late in soil development. In situ decomposition rates of Metrosideros polymorpha litter were highest at two intermediate—aged sites with soil fertility (20 000 yr and 150 000 yr), and lowest at the less—fertile beginning (300 yr) and endpoint (4.1 x 106 yr) of the chronosequence. M. polymorpha leaves collected from these same four sites, and decomposed in a common site, suggested that leaves from intermediate—aged sites were inherently more decomposable than those from the youngest and oldest sites. Both litter tissue quality and the soil environment appeared to influence rates of decomposition directly. The highest mean soil N2O emissions (809 mg°m—2°d—1) were measured at the 20 000—yr—old site, which also had the highest soil nitrogen fertility status. Plant communities at all six chronosequence sites were dominated primarily by M. Polymorpha, and to a lesser extent by several other genera of trees and shrubs. There were, however, differences in overall vegetation community composition among the sites. Using a detrended correspondence analysis (DECORANA), we found that a high proportion of species variance among the sites (eigenvalue = 0.71) can be explained by site age and thus soil developmental stage. Overall, long—term soil development across the chronosequence largely coincides with the conceptual model of Walker and Syers (1976). How P is distributed among different organic and inorganic fractions at a given stage of soil development provides a useful context of evaluating contemporary cycling of P and other nutrients, and for deter...

How does pedogenesis drive plant diversity?

“…Soil chronosequences, by contrast, enable comparisons between ecosystems within much smaller regions, where factors such as climate and parent material are controlled [50,51]. The available data reveal that total plant species richness usually increases with soil age across soil chronosequences spanning boreal, temperate, subtropical, and Mediterranean climates [4,5,24] (Figure II). Together, these global and smallerscale patterns motivate the search for underlying mechanisms that can explain the greater plant diversity on older soils.…”

“…Soil chronosequences provide some support for the productivity-diversity hypothesis, in that total plant species richness generally increases as ecosystem retrogression proceeds (and productivity declines) [4,5]. By contrast, according to the resource-ratio theory [12], higher plant diversity is maintained under equilibrium conditions if multiple resources limit productivity [14], such that a positive relation is expected between the number of colimiting resources and plant diversity [14].…”

“…The 'species pool hypothesis' proposes that plant species richness in a local community is directly influenced by the number of species that can potentially colonize the site and are physiologically adapted to the local environmental conditions [46]. For example, it has been suggested that the higher local plant diversity of older Hawaiian islands simply reflects their larger regional species pools, due to more opportunities for colonization and speciation [4]. However, many chronosequences cover a sufficiently small area that most species can disperse easily across the entire area (e.g., [10]).…”

Genetic analysis of an ephemeral intraspecific hybrid zone in the hypervariable tree, Metrosideros polymorpha, on Hawai‘i Island

“…Previous studies of vars. incana and glaberrima on Hawaiʻi Island documented different leaf nitrogen contents , and the differential adaptation of their seedlings to light and nitrogen (Morrison and Stacy, 2014), both of which vary significantly between new and old substrates on east Hawaiʻi Island (Crews et al, 1995). Other studies of glabrous and pubescent seedlings or trees from lower elevations (indicative of these two varieties) grown in a common garden revealed differences in water retention (Stemmermann, 1983), cuticle thickness and possibly osmotic potentials and photosynthesis rates (Kitayama et al, 1997).…”

Interactions between bacterial carbon monoxide and hydrogen consumption and plant development on recent volcanic deposits

“…Analyses of these patterns have contributed to the formulation of ecological theories and to a greater understanding of biogeochemical controls of ecosystem dynamics (Hooper and Vitousek, 1997;Vitousek and Farrington, 1997;Chadwick et al, 1999). For instance, the roles of phosphorus, nitrogen and eolian nutrient inputs have been clearly documented through long-term observations of Hawaiian chronosequences (Crews et al, 1995;Chadwick et al, 1999;Neff et al, 2000).…”