Changes in the quality of doctor–patient communication between 1982 and 2001: an observational study on hypertension care as perceived by patients and general practitioners

Abstract

BackgroundThe rise of evidence-based medicine may have implications for the doctor–patient interaction. In recent decades, a shift towards a more task-oriented approach in general practice indicates a development towards more standardised healthcare.ObjectiveTo examine whether this shift is accompanied by changes in perceived quality of doctor–patient communication.DesignGP observers and patient observers performed quality assessments of Dutch General Practice consultations on hypertension videotaped in 1982–1984 and 2000–2001. In the first cohort (1982–1984) 81 patients were recorded by 23 GPs and in the second cohort (2000–2001) 108 patients were recorded by 108 GPs. The GP observers and patient observers rated the consultations on a scale from 1 to 10 on three quality dimensions: medical technical quality, psychosocial quality and quality of interpersonal behaviour. Multilevel regression analyses were used to test whether a change occurred over time.ResultsThe findings showed a significant improvement over time on all three dimensions. There was no difference between the quality assessments of GP observers and patient observers. The three different dimensions were moderately to highly correlated and the assessments of GP observers showed less variability in the second cohort.ConclusionsHypertension consultations in general practice in the Netherlands received higher quality assessments by general practitioners and patients on medical technical quality, psychosocial quality and the quality of interpersonal behaviour in 2000–2001 as compared with the 1980s. The shift towards a more task-oriented approach in hypertension consultations does not seem to detract from individual attention for the patient. In addition, there is less variation between general practitioners in the quality assessments of more recent consultations. The next step in this line of research is to unravel the factors that determine patients' quality assessments of doctor–patient communication.

The Satisfaction Level of Patients Seeking Dental Care in the Slovak Republic: A Cross-sectional Questionnaire Study (Original paper)

“…Dentists and patients is a multidimensional concept that includes medical technology, psychosocial aspects and interaction (11). Proper communication skills have often been neglected in medical education in the EU as well as in the USA (12).…”

Long-term effect of communication training on the relationship between physicians’ self-efficacy and performance

“…However, changing the standard of communication has been slow and difficult [4-8] and the long term impact of communication skills training on physician's assessment of their own communication skills is unknown.…”

Managing barriers to empathy in the clinical encounter: a qualitative interview study with GPs

“…10 The emphasis in general practice on evidence-based and protocol-driven care, and the observed reduction in viewing the patient as an individual, has caused an ideological debate. 6,11,12 To achieve insight into different factors playing a role in GPpatient communication, models of the medical consultation were constructed. 9,13 In these models, empathy was regarded as an important tool to establish a personcentred approach.…”