Changing Minds and Changing Laws: How New Zealand Sex Workers and Their Allies Shaped Decriminalisation in New Zealand

Abstract

Introduction This article provides insight into a rare instance of a collaborative governance approach to sex work that led to the decriminalisation, design and implementation of the sex work policy governance framework in New Zealand with the Prostitution Reform Act 2003. Methods Drawing on a sample of 17 interviews conducted between the years 2012 and 2019 in addition to associated archival material originating from government and non-government sectors including sex worker representative organisations. Results It finds that non-sex workers’ endorsement for the decriminalisation of sex work was motivated by the New Zealand Prostitutes Collective (NZPC) and occurred primarily within a human rights and harm minimisation framework. But that during the lobbying and parliamentary process, amendments to the Bill emerged that contradicted the NZPC’s main goal which was for sex work to be recognised as a legitimate labour activity and for all sex workers to benefit from decriminalisation and policy reform. Conclusions As such, this article broadens the scope of analysis related to the sex worker rights movement by examining how and why sex workers and their allies came to communicate and act on the impetus for sex work law reform and how it affected policy outcomes. Policy Implications Those involved in collaborative governance sex work law reform projects could consider adopting Östegren’s typology of repressive, restrictive or integrative approaches to sex work law reform in negotiations that concern regulation and policies.

Framing the Windows of Prostitution: Unfolding Histories in Amsterdam’s Redesign of Its Famous Red-Light District

“…Policy renewal should foreground the complex and multifaceted history of sex work in Amsterdam and consider the livelihood of sex workers, brothel owners, their representative organizations, and other residents of Amsterdam's city center over spatial arguments. The policy should actively engage with their voices and concerns, as other research has shown that collaborative governance can be a useful approach to improve the occupational health and safety of sex workers, while also improving local cohesion (Aroney, 2021;Blanchard et al, 2013;Kerrigan et al, 2015). Giving priority to the perspectives of sex workers and the community may potentially offer a more effective approach to achieving Project 1012's and other city regeneration plans' ostensible objectives of reducing crime and nuisance and enhancing living conditions for the people in Amsterdam.…”

HIV prevention in individuals engaged in sex work

“…There are now numerous examples from around the world of how peer networks of support have coalesced into successful political movements, ensuring sex workers’ advocate for their own priorities and tailor activities and programmes to their local risk environment with resulting reductions in their vulnerability to HIV and other adverse health and social outcomes [33,43–48]. In some cases, sex workers have forged powerful coalitions that contributed to changing national policy, such as the role of the New Zealand Prostitutes Collective in achieving decriminalization in Aotearoa New Zealand [49,50].…”