Emerging polymeric foams exhibiting unique microstructure of microspherical shells with reinforcing dense microspheres creates a new opportunity for impact-tolerant foam paddings in sport gears applications. This paper describes the static response of reinforced microcell consisting of an outer spherical shell and uniformly distributed microspheres while quantifying the stiffening effect. The distribution of the microspheres is illustrated using the Fourier series, allowing tuning of the reinforcing strategy. Expressions of the external and internal works are derived, whereas the Ritz energy method is adopted to calculate the deformations due to a compressive load distributed over a range of areas. Emphasis is given to the effect of the geometrical attributes of the microcell and the reinforcing microspheres on the resulting deformation response and stiffening effect. The framework is used to investigate the response of several case studies to elucidate the effects of relative radii ratio, reinforcement density, microcell wall thickness, and loading configurations on the stiffness. A new normalized strain energy parameter is introduced to simplify and accelerate the analysis while providing insights on the underpinnings of the observed buckling response. The results strongly suggest the viability of the newly discovered foam microstructure in managing static loads while providing an opportunity to strategically tune the mechanical response using the analytical framework presented herein.