Iron-responsive elements (IREs), a natural group of mRNA-specific sequences, bind iron regulatory proteins (IRPs) differentially and fold into hairpins [with a hexaloop (HL) CAGUGX] with helical distortions: an internal loop/bulge (IL/B) (UGC/C) or C-bulge. C-bulge iso-IREs bind IRP2 more poorly, as oligomers (n ) 28-30), and have a weaker signal response in vivo. Two trans-loop GC base pairs occur in the ferritin IRE (IL/B and HL) but only one in C-bulge iso-IREs (HL); metal ions and protons perturb the IL/B [Gdaniec et al. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 1505-1512. IRE function (translation) and physical properties (T m and accessibility to nucleases) are now compared for IL/B and C-bulge IREs and for HL mutants. Conversion of the IL/B into a C-bulge by a single deletion in the IL/B or by substituting the HL CG base pair with UA both derepressed ferritin synthesis 4-fold in rabbit reticulocyte lysates (IRP1 + IRP2), confirming differences in IRP2 binding observed for the oligomers. Since the engineered C-bulge IRE was more helical near the IL/B [Cu(phen) 2 resistant] and more stable (T m increased) and the HL mutant was less helical near the IL/B (ribonuclease T1 sensitive) and less stable (T m decreased), both CG trans-loop base pairs contribute to maximum IRP2 binding and translational regulation. The 1 H NMR spectrum of the Mg-IRE complex revealed, in contrast to the localized IL/B effects of Co(III) hexaammine observed previously, perturbation of the IL/B plus HL and interloop helix. The lower stability and greater helix distortion in the ferritin IL/B-IRE compared to the C-bulge iso-IREs create a combinatorial set of RNA/protein interactions that control protein synthesis rates with a range of signal sensitivities.Awareness of mRNA regulation as a mechanism for controlling gene expression is increasing. The iso-IRE (iron responsive element) 1 family of mRNA regulatory elements recognized by the cognate proteins, iron regulatory proteins (IRPs), is one of the most extensively characterized mRNA regulatory targets. However, knowledge about mRNA regulation is in its infancy compared to understanding of DNA regulation such as hormone response elements recognized by hormone nuclear receptors (1). The ancient nature of the proteins encoded in IRE-containing, animal mRNAs (e.g., aconitase, ferritin), the homology of the IRPs to aconitases, and the recent detection of functional IREs and IRPs in bacteria (2) as well as animals suggest that the IRE/IRP interaction is also ancient, possibly representing regulation in an RNA world.The common structural features of iso-IREs are a hairpin hexaloop (CAGUGX) with a trans-loop GC base pair and a helical stem (3-5). The GC base pair in the hexaloop has a large effect on the stabilization of the overall IRE structure (3,6). A disordered C residue occurs in all IREs (4, 5). In many iso-IREs, the disordered C is a bulge in the helix of the IRE stem (4). In another type of iso-IRE, the disordered C residue is part of a set of four conserved residues [UGC-(16 nucleotides)-C]...