Herein, we lay out the pros and cons of constructing (hydro) gels from polymer networks held together by noncovalent interactions or covalent bonds. Hydrogel materials currently find many applications in personal care products, biomaterials, coatings, and plant fertilizers. They have a large potential for future application in sensing, drug delivery, soft robotics, and biohybrid or biointerfacing materials. To scientists working in those fields, the choice of material type may depend heavily on the intended application and associated required properties. There, it can be useful to consider a generalized overview and comparison of hydrogel structure, properties, and performance in various scenarios.Hydrogels are fascinating soft materials with unique properties. Many biological systems are based on hydrogel-like structures, underlining their versatility and relevance. The properties of hydrogels strongly depend on the structure of the building blocks they are composed of, as well as the nature of interactions between them in the network structure. Herein, gel networks made by supramolecular interactions are compared to covalent macromolecular networks, drawing conclusions about their performance and application as responsive materials.