Phosphosiderite (FePO4⋅2H2O) is the monoclinic (P21/n) polymorph of orthorhombic strengite (Pbca), which is isostructural to scorodite (FeAsO4⋅2H2O). While the structural incorporation of As5+ into strengite can be attributed to a fractional miscibility between strengite and scorodite, the incorporation of As5+ into phosphosiderite and its dehydration product FePO4 (P 21/n) has never been investigated until now. Phosphosiderite, synthesized under hydrothermal conditions at 200 °C in the presence of arsenic, incorporates 0.044±0.001, 0.084±0.001, 0.165±0.002, 0.425±0.004 and 0.844±0.014 wt.% As at initial molar As/Fe solution ratios of 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 0.5 and 1, respectively. With increasing As content, the P concentration in phosphosiderite decreases by 1.02 to 1.58 P atoms for each incorporated As. The unit‐cell parameters a, b, c and β increase from As‐free phosphosiderite with 5.326(6) Å, 9.793(8) Å, 8.709(3) Å and 90.54(0)° to 5.329(0) Å, 9.797(5) Å, 8.713(7) Å and 90.56(7)°, respectively, for phosphosiderite synthesized at an initial molar As/Fe solution ratio of 1. Single crystal X‐ray diffraction indicates that the P position in phosphosiderite is occupied by As with about 2 %. X‐ray absorption spectroscopy displays only As5+, which resides on the P position in phosphosiderite in a local coordination similar to strengite and scorodite, indicating the structural incorporation of As5+ into a strengite/scorodite‐like arrangement.