“…Taking into account the formation mechanism of TiO 2 nanotubes, 11,12 the Sn ion removed by the Na ion might not be able to bind with the Ti ion again, because Ti 1− x Sn x O 2 particles in the strong basic solution (10 M NaOH) may become an amorphous, layered compound, and a layer separation process may occur during washing with deionized water and HCl. Also, Sn ion is more unstable in an NaOH solution rather than in a slightly acidic solution (hence in low concentrations of HCl solution), and tends to exist as a dissolution form of SnO 2 2− or SnO 3 2− 22 . Consequently, the dissolved Sn ion may get washed off during the ion exchange process.…”