The novel cascade radical reaction of 2-(phenylalkynyl)aryl radicals with 4-Y-phenyl isothiocyanates (Y = H, OMe, Me, Cl, CN) provides a useful one-pot protocol for the production of 8-Y-substituted (12) and/or 9-Y-substituted benzothieno[2,3-b]quinolines (11). The whole process entails primary formation of an alpha-(2-alkynylarylsulfanyl)imidoyl radical that undergoes smooth 5-exo-dig cyclization onto the alkynyl triple bond. The derived 1-phenylvinyl radical then exhibits six-membered cyclization onto the isothiocyanate ring, to give 11, and/or five-membered ipso-cyclization to an azaspiro intermediate, whose eventual rearrangement affords 12. The overall findings clearly showed that the relative proportion of the outcoming isomeric benzothienoquinolines 11 and 12 can be markedly affected by the nature of the original isothiocyanate substituent. Moreover, the findings also furnished the first chemical evidence that enhancing the electrophilic power of the employed radical can properly enhance the reactivity of aryl radicals toward isothiocyanates.