“…Old, low [α/Fe] stars are found in the dwarf spheroid galaxies, but accreting a Sagittarius-like object would not explain the pattern, because the low [α/Fe] stars in Sagittarius have too low metallicities (e.g., Venn et al 2004). In the simulations of Rahimi et al (2010), the bulges experience a series of mergers over a period of ∼5 Gyr, leading to populations of "old", "intermediate" and "young" stars. The distributions of [Mg/Fe] for these populations do show some old stars with low [Mg/Fe], (as well the expected shift to low [Mg/Fe] for the younger stars) but they caution that their code suppresses mixing among gas particles, leading to artificially high abundance ratio dispersions.…”