Chemosensory proteins in the CSP4 clade evolved as plant immunity suppressors before two suborders of plant-feeding hemipteran insects diverged

Abstract

Chemosensory proteins (CSPs) are small globular proteins with hydrophobic binding pockets that have a role in detection of chemicals, regulation of development and growth and host seeking behaviour and feeding of arthropods. Here, we show that a CSP has evolved to modulate plant immune responses. Firstly, we found that the green peach aphid Myzus persicae CSP Mp10, which is delivered into the cytoplasm of plant cells, suppresses the reactive oxygen species (ROS) bursts to both aphid and bacterial elicitors in Arabidopsis thaliana and Nicotiana benthamiana. Aphid RNA interference studies demonstrated that Mp10 modulates the first layer of the plant defence response, specifically the BAK1 pathway.We identified Mp10 homologs in diverse plant-sucking insect species, including aphids, whiteflies, psyllids and leafhoppers, but not in other insect species, including blood-feeding hemipteran insects. We found that Mp10 homologs from other splant-sucking insect species are also capable of suppressing plant ROS. Together, these data and phylogenetic analyses provides evidence that an ancestral Mp10-like sequence acquired plant ROS suppression activity before the divergence of plant-sucking insect species over 250 million years ago. SignificanceAphids, whiteflies, psyllids, leafhoppers and planthoppers are plant-sucking insects of the order Hemiptera that cause dramatic crop losses via direct feeding damage and vectoring of plant pathogens. Chemosensory proteins (CSPs) regulate behavioural and developmental processes in arthropods. Here we show that the CSP Mp10 of the green peach aphid Myzus persicae is an effector that suppresses plant reactive oxygen species (ROS) bursts and the first layer of plant defence responses. Surprisingly, Mp10 homologs are present in diverse plant-feeding hemipteran species, but not blood-feeding ones. An ancestral Mp10-like sequence most likely acquired ROS suppression activity before the divergence of plantsucking insect species 250 million years ago.

The coming of age of EvoMPMI: evolutionary molecular plant-microbe interactions across multiple timescales

“…New insights into the evolution of the Mp10 effector of the green peach aphid points to marked differences with microbial pathogen effectors. Whereas the majority of plant pathogen effectors have rapidly diversified with little sequence and functional conservation , Mp10 is relatively conserved across hemipteran insects and belongs to the widespread chemosensory protein 4 clade (CSP4) (Drurey et al 2017). Remarkably, the immunosuppression activity of Mp10 evolved via gain-of-function mutations over 250 million years ago, prior to the divergence of plantsucking insect species (Drurey et al 2017).…”

“…Whereas the majority of plant pathogen effectors have rapidly diversified with little sequence and functional conservation , Mp10 is relatively conserved across hemipteran insects and belongs to the widespread chemosensory protein 4 clade (CSP4) (Drurey et al 2017). Remarkably, the immunosuppression activity of Mp10 evolved via gain-of-function mutations over 250 million years ago, prior to the divergence of plantsucking insect species (Drurey et al 2017). As more effectors are discovered in aphids and other plant parasitic insects, it will be interesting to determine whether they would exhibit similar evolutionary trends.…”

Plant–arthropod interactions: who is the winner?

“…For example, the M. persicae Mp10 effector suppressed flg22-induced but not chitininduced ROS production (Bos et al, 2010). Furthermore, Mp10 was shown to act in the BAK1 pathway (Drurey et al, 2017). Myzus persicae Mp1 promoted aphid virulence by targeting a vacuolar sorting protein (VSP52) from its preferred host plants Arabidopis and potato, but not with VSP52 from poor-host barley and M. truncaluta (Rodriguez et al, 2017).…”

The coming of age of EvoMPMI: evolutionary molecular plant–microbe interactions across multiple timescales

“…New insights into the evolution of the Mp10 effector of the green peach aphid points to marked differences with microbial pathogen effectors. Whereas the majority of plant pathogen effectors have rapidly diversified with little sequence and functional conservation [34], Mp10 is relatively conserved across hemipteran insects and belongs to the widespread chemosensory protein 4 clade (CSP4) [35]. Remarkably, the immunosuppression activity of Mp10 evolved via gain-of-function mutations over 250 million years ago, prior to the divergence of plant-sucking insect species [35].…”

“…Whereas the majority of plant pathogen effectors have rapidly diversified with little sequence and functional conservation [34], Mp10 is relatively conserved across hemipteran insects and belongs to the widespread chemosensory protein 4 clade (CSP4) [35]. Remarkably, the immunosuppression activity of Mp10 evolved via gain-of-function mutations over 250 million years ago, prior to the divergence of plant-sucking insect species [35]. As more effectors are discovered in aphids and other plant parasitic insects, it will be interesting to determine whether they would exhibit similar evolutionary trends.…”