Child Compared with Parent Perceptions of Child-Level Food Security

Abstract

Background There is a need to directly and accurately conceptualize and measure food insecurity in children as part of surveillance and public health efforts. Objective The aim of this study was to compare parent and child perceptions of child-level food security status via questionnaires within a large, ethnically diverse population. Methods Cross-sectional baseline data from a cluster-randomized controlled trial involving primarily low-income, Hispanic third- to fifth-grade students and their parents were used for analysis. The sample consisted of 2408 dyadic (parent and child) pairs. Parents completed the 8-item child-referenced Household Food Security Survey Module and their responses were compared with an adaption of the 5-item Child Food Security Assessment completed by their child. Levels of association between child and parent perceptions within dyads were calculated using Goodman and Kruskal's γ statistic. A mixed-effects binomial logistic regression model was used to model discordance as a function of child, parent, and household sociodemographic characteristics. Results The child sample was 53% girls, mean age of 9 y, and 63% were Hispanic. The parent sample was 86% women and 65% Hispanic. Child and parent perceptions of child-level food security agreed only 21.7% of the time. There was a weak positive association between child and parent perceptions of child-level food security (γ = 0.162, P < 0.001). Children perceived themselves as less food secure than their parents’ perception 70.1% of the time. Household receipt of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits was associated with greater odds of discordant food security perceptions, whereas female children, older children, and parents not working were characteristics associated with lower odds of discordant perceptions. Conclusions Results, in combination with the existing literature, suggest that parent perceptions of child-level food insecurity may underestimate child-level food insecurity experiences. Inaccurate estimations or underestimations of the true prevalence of child-level food insecurity could be detrimental to maternal and child health efforts. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT02668744.

Food insecurity, housing instability, and dietary quality among children with sickle cell disease: Assessment from a single urban center

“…Per USDA methodology, we only reported and analyzed household food insecurity experiences reported by caregivers. However, food insecurity reports between parents and children may be discordant 44,55,56 . Children may also be more aware of their caregivers’ struggles with meeting the family's food needs, and thus add to their stresses 57 .…”

“…[51][52][53] Study limitations include a single-site, clinic-based convenience sample of modest size with possible selection bias for those who attended their child's scheduled hematology visit during our sampling However, food insecurity reports between parents and children may be discordant. 44,55,56 Children may also be more aware of their caregivers' struggles with meeting the family's food needs, and thus add to their stresses. 57 The FFQ reliance on self-report increased vulnerability to social approval and recall bias.…”

Perceived Food Insecurity, Dietary Quality, and Unfavorable Food Intake among Children and Adolescents from Economically Disadvantaged Households

“…Moreover, the experiences of food insecurity in children or adolescents are typically obtained by interviewing their parents or caregivers, which may not be accurate as they may not know what the children or adolescents eat outside the home. Indeed, the agreement between children and parents regarding children's food insecurity is only 21.7%, and parents tend to underreport it [14]. In Taiwan, the average duration of school and afterschool activities for children and adolescents is 9.5 h (7:30 am to 5:00 pm), which is different from other countries.…”

“…Cronbach' α is 0.874. Food insecurity is indicated by a score of ≥2 for both question-naires and details of questionnaires can be found elsewhere [8,14,21,22].…”

Urban Youth Perspectives on Food Insecurity during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Evidence from the COACHES Study

“…Youth perceptions of their own food security status are less widely surveyed. The limited research comparing caregiverand child-reported food insecurity in the same household has indicated that children may perceive themselves as food insecure, even when their caregivers do not [5,6].…”