Chinese students’ participation: the effect of cultural factors

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to provide for Western educators of international Chinese and Confucian Heritage Culture (CHC) students the first integrated review of kiasu, the “fear of missing out”, and its consequences for learning, teaching, and future research. Design/methodology/approach – A review of the economic importance of international Chinese students is provided, followed by consideration of the pedagogical consequences of restricted participation in educational activities by the so-called “silent Chinese student”. Examination of research on international Chinese students and their source cultures established significant gaps and misunderstandings in the generally accepted understandings of CHCs, especially with respect to the actual practices used in Western and Chinese teaching. More importantly, the participation-related implications of kiasu within the context of broader cultural characteristics are described and implications drawn for teaching practices and research. Findings – While many Western university teachers are aware of the “silent Chinese student” phenomenon, few understand its underlying reasons, especially the kiasu mindset and its relationship to other cultural elements. Kiasu actively impedes the interaction of international Chinese students with their teachers and restricts collaboration with peers, thereby limiting educational achievement. Specific tactics for amelioration are reviewed and recommendations are provided, while an agenda for future research is outlined. Practical implications – Western teachers need to normalise and encourage Chinese student participation in class activities using tactics that have been demonstrated to improve outcomes for Chinese students, but that also assist students generally. These include both within-class and electronic interaction tools. Social implications – More culturally sensitive understanding of the impact of cultural differences on teaching effectiveness. While some effective responses to these already exist, further research is needed to expand the skill-set of Western teachers who work with international Chinese students. Originality/value – This paper provides the first systematic integration of the kiasu phenomenon with educational practice and research.

Chinese students’ social integration into the university community: hearing the students’ voices

“…Much of the research into Chinese students studying abroad has focused on their academic life, with particular attention paid to their levels of participation in class (e.g. Hodkinson and Proropat 2014;Liu 2002), their styles of learning (e.g. Jin andCortazzi 2006, 2011) and more recently their levels of academic attainment in comparison with their peers (e.g.…”

Chinese Students’ Expectations Versus Reality When Studying on a UK-China Transnational Chemistry Degree Program

“…This apparent unwillingness to ask questions in class, a behaviour encouraged and expected in western classroom settings, has been discussed previously in literature (Dougherty and Wall, 1991;Hodkinson and Poropat, 2014) who describe the phenomenon of 'Kiasu' where Chinese students are described as being generally less willing to ask questions in class for fear of losing 'face'. Students wish to avoid the embarrassment of providing a wrong answer by asking a question that others already know the answer to, or even stand out too much by answering too many questions correctly.…”

The Integration of International Chinese Students Into Local Singaporean Community

“…According to the research of Chinese students' participation, many Western university professors found the common phenomenon: "silent Chinese student", which explains the fact that the majority of international Chinese students without language confidence usually keep quiet during classes or extracurricular activities. Thus, this behavior impedes the interaction of international Chinese students with their teachers and peers restricting collaboration and limiting their educational achievement (Hodkinson & Poropat, 2014).…”