Two dimethyl α-hydroxy-arylmethylphosphonates (aryl = Ph and 2-MeOPh) were subjected to optical resolution via diastereomer complex formation applying the acidic calcium salt of O,O′-dibenzoyl-(2R,3R)-tartaric acid as the resolving agent. The dominating diastereomer complexes, whose structure was determined by single crystal X-ray measurements, were obtained in 96% and 68% diastereomer excess values, respectively. After decomposing the diastereomer formations by extraction, and after recrystallizations, the major enantiomer (S and R, respectively) of the α-hydroxyphosphonates were prepared in enantiomeric excess values of 96% and 68%, respectively. The stereostructure of the two α-hydroxy-arylmethylphosphonates was again established by X-ray measurements. Detailed study on the X-ray data allowed valuable conclusions on the nature of the coordination in the complexes (intermolecular interactions), and on the H-bonding.