The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) is of great importance due to its applications for alternative energies and environmental remediation. Therefore, controlling the selectivity toward the four-electrons pathway is of current interest. In this work, using density functional theory calculations, we give a detailed explanation of the role that transition metal centers play as single-atom catalysts to generate either the four or the two-electron pathway. The model system is the TM−N 4 V 2 graphene monolayer (TM = Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu), where N stands for pyridinic nitrogen species and V for vacancies. Our results show that the magnetic moment present in the Cr, Mn, and Fe results in a strong O 2 * chemisorption. This favors the O 2 * bond breaking after the first hydrogenation, resulting in O* and OH* (dissociative mechanism, which could lead toward the four-electrons pathway). In the case of Co, with its lower magnetic moment, a chemisorbed O 2 * molecule is also obtained, but the reaction follows an associative mechanism, since after the first hydrogenation, an OOH* is formed. Afterward, the reaction also proceeds toward the four-electron pathway. According to our free energy analyses (ΔG), the monolayers with Fe and Mn have the smallest overpotentials, making them the best choices as catalysts for the four electrons ORR. The nonmagnetic Ni or the low magnetic moment Cu atoms only interact weakly with O 2 in a physisorption-type mechanism, leading to the two-electron pathway. The results presented here shed light on the parameters�as the magnetic moment�that help control the selectivity toward the four-electron reaction and they will certainly contribute to the design of electrocatalytic materials, depending on the required application.