“…Constructive reviews by Prof. S. Kobayashi and Dr. [4] Al and Cl of K -rich calcic amphiboles with [4] Al ≥ 1.5 apfu and [A] (Na + K) ≥ 0.5 apfu. The chemical data are from Borley (1963), Krutov and Vinogradova (1966), Leelanandam (1970), Czamanske et al (1977), Hawthorne and Grundy (1977), Dick and Robinson (1979), Sharma (1981), Shimazaki et al (1984), Matsubara and Motoyoshi (1985), van Marcke de Lummen and Verkaeren (1985), Gulyaeva et al (1986), Suwa et al (1987), Sawaki (1989), Morrison (1991), Enami et al (1992), Oberti et al (1993), Shira ishi et al (1994, Deer et al (1997), Robinson et al (1997), Sato et al (1997), Sokolova et al (2000), Chukanov et al (2002), Mazdab (2003), Banno et al (2004), Pekov et al (2005), Korinevskiy and Korinevskiy (2006), Sautter et al (2006) and Banno et al (this study). The Cl contents of K -rich amphiboles described by Shimazaki et al (1984) and Sawaki (1989) were not given, but they pointed out that qualitative analyses of these amphiboles show no appreciable amount of chlorine.…”