Chronic crisis and nuclear disaster humanitarianism: recuperation of Chernobyl and Fukushima children in Italy

Abstract

This article situates Henrik Vigh’s concept of ‘chronic crisis’ in social disaster research and humanitarian studies in order to explore how child survivors experience and address the prolonged consequences of disasters. The rationale for mobilising the concept of chronic crisis is that it opens up possibilities for exploring the dynamics and multidimensionality of disasters and humanitarian responses to them. Using the example of nuclear disasters, the article looks at the enduring humanitarian initiatives of Italian non-governmental organisations in recuperating Chernobyl and Fukushima children in Italy. It focuses on the opportunities, challenges and outcomes of these recuperative programmes, and underscores the non-linearity of survivor agency. The article argues that chronic crisis in nuclear disasters can simultaneously contribute to deterioration and ruination of survivors’ lives, catharsis, and hope. It is further argued that humanitarianism can shape chronic crisis either by exacerbating the alreadyprecarious conditions of human existence (through social discrimination and prejudice), or by alleviating survivor suffering (through social and cultural support).<br/><br/>Key messages<br/>Chronic crisis is a way to understand humanitarian disasters beyond chronic emergency and protracted crisis.<br/><br/>Chronic crisis occupies an ambiguous space between normalcy and emergency.<br/><br/>Nuclear disaster humanitarianism is a practice of a simultaneous healing from and reinforcement of chronic crisis.<br/><br/>Nuclear disaster humanitarianism can alleviate chronic crisis for some but reinforce it for others.

Humanitarianism, mobility and kinship: a reply to ‘Chronic crisis and nuclear disaster humanitarianism: recuperation of Chernobyl and Fukushima children in Italy’ by Ekatherina Zhukova

“…This is a reply to 'Chronic crisis and nuclear disaster humanitarianism: recuperation of Chernobyl and Fukushima children in Italy' by Ekatherina Zhukova (2022). The article on 'Chronic crisis and nuclear disaster humanitarianism' makes a number of valuable points in relation to how practices of vernacular humanitarianism, such as hosting children in Italian families, can have ambiguous effects.…”