A 50 y/o man was recently diagnosed with chronic hepatitis C after a life insurance physical. He was very surprised by the diagnosis since he led an active lifestyle, exercised regularly, and did not smoke nor drink any alcohol, except a glass of wine once or twice per month. He had experimented with injecting drugs during his freshman year at college. Over the last 5 years, he had undergone regular physicals and never was told of any "liver problems". In reviewing laboratory data from his referring provider, liver enzymes had been checked on two previous annual physicals with serum ALT activities of 44 and 41 U/L. Physical examination shows a healthy male, BMI =24, without any stigmata of chronic liver disease. Currently, serum ALT activity is 44 U/L and HCV RNA is >700,000 IU/mL with genotype 1. Platelet count was 244,000 cells/mm 3 .
The DilemmaThis patient is a generally healthy man who was likely infected with chronic hepatitis C for over 30 years prior to the consultation. Despite the prolonged duration of infection, he had no signs or symptoms of hepatitis C or advanced liver disease. There is historical evidence that his serum ALT activities have been persistently within the normal range. When confronted with such an individual, clinicians may speculate that aggressive treatment of hepatitis C in this vigorous patient is unwarranted. However, further evaluation and management can be planned only after considering the natural history of chronic hepatitis C infection with persistently normal ALT levels and the outcome of therapy in these patients.
Defining normal serum ALT activityElevations of serum alanine amontransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferases (AST) activity serve as important markers for liver injury. The finding of an abnormal ALT in a patient, even in the absence of clinical signs or symptoms, should prompt further evaluation for occult liver disease. Hereditary hemochromatosis, chronic viral hepatitis, and nonalcoholic steatohepatitis are frequently overlooked causes of asymptomatic ALT abnormalities that could have serious consequences over time. In order to define "abnormal ALT" which would prompt clinical investigation, healthcare providers must be confident in the definition of "normal" ALT, a value below which they can be secure that liver disease is unlikely. However, despite the importance of these definitions to general medical care and the seemingly simple dichotomy that should be represented by a laboratory test above or