“…This research has produced critical insight into how the enclave has emerged as an architectural and financial solution to a variety of crises-economic, sociological, and political. In doing so, this scholarship revealed how the fortification of residential geographies shifts distinctions between the public and the private (Davis, 1992;Graham and Marvin, 2001;Kaviraj, 1997;Soja, 2000), how the enclave (re)produces neoliberal urban policies that privilege the consumption of global lifestyles (Kuldova, 2017;Pow, 2009), and how designed natures entangle ideologies of environmental protection with exclusionary models of citizenship (Ballard and Jones, 2011;Baviskar, 2020). Much of this work has focused on those disaffiliated from, displaced by, or designed out of these spaces (Dinzey-Flores, 2013;Murray, 2017;Sawyer et al, 2021), and on the political economy of the bright developments producing the shadows into which they are forced (Sassen, 2014).…”