Civil Death, Radical Protest and The Theatre of Punishment in the Reign of Alexander II*

Abstract

Civil executions in Imperial Russia were punitive ceremonies that were staged before crowds and presaged a sentence of penal labour and lifelong exile in Siberia. Intended to underline the absolute supremacy of the autocracy, they choreographed the public humiliation of the criminal and collective condemnation from the crowds who gathered to witness the stripping away of the rights and entitlements that gave civil life in the autocracy its meaning. Many took place without incident, and followed the ritual of debasement and expulsion endorsed by the state. Yet when at the civil executions of revolutionaries during the reign of Alexander II both convicts and spectators departed from the state’s script of public humiliation and orderly opprobrium, the performance of monarchical power and autocratic justice proved liable to subversion. Russian radicals sometimes succeeded in hijacking the ceremony to denounce despotism and proclaim an alternative vision of activism, solidarity, and revolution. In so doing, they contested the autocrat’s position as the source of status, rights and, ultimately, of sovereignty. Building on studies of law, punishment, performance, and the revolutionary movement, this article demonstrates how radicals and their supporters recast “scenarios of power” as “scenarios of rebellion”.

Words on Trial: Morality and Legality in Frida Vigdorova's Journalism

“…True to the intelligentsia vision of natural rights that are not codified from above but inherent in the human condition, Herzen places moral justice in the hands of a community of "friends" who answer to something higher than the formulations of positive law. 51 By recording the morally indifferent language that she believed to characterize courtroom rituals, Vigdorova situated both herself and her readers within that community of judgment.…”