“…The CSR (and hence the CSR reporting) did, at least on the surface, engage with relevant socioeconomic issuesbanks, for instance, to some extent stepping into the space created by a rolling back of the State influenced by neo-liberalismbut in the incoherent and ad hoc way that is familiar to Western critics. Banks' CSR, where it might be seen as positive was thus also seen as limited in its piecemeal filling of gaps left by the regime's adoption of neo-liberal policies, as indicated by interviewee M20, a credit manager (see Alvarez-Ossorio, 2017). Some indicated there was concern to only basically/minimally comply with international drivers and the positive spirit of CSR reporting and that this, with weak regulation, meant more form than substance.…”