Creatine, a naturally occurring compound in mammals, is crucial in energy metabolism, particularly within muscle and brain tissues. While creatine metabolism in cancer has been studied for several decades, emerging studies are beginning to clarify the sometimes-contradictory role creatine has in either the promotion or inhibition of cancer. On one hand, creatine can directly enhance anti-tumor CD8+ T-cell activity and induce tumor apoptosis, contributing to antitumor immunity. Conversely, other studies have shown that creatine can facilitate cancer cell growth and migration by providing an energy source and activating several signaling pathways. This review will examine what is known about creatine in cancer biology, with a focus on understanding its roles across different cellular compartments. Lastly, we discuss the emerging roles of creatine metabolism, providing exciting new insights into this often-overlooked pathway. This review highlights the complex role of creatine in cancer development and treatment, offering insights into its potential as both a therapeutic target and a risk factor in oncogenesis.