Classification of polyhedral shapes from individual anisotropically resolved cryo-electron tomography reconstructions

Abstract

BackgroundCryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) enables 3D imaging of macromolecular structures. Reconstructed cryo-ET images have a “missing wedge” of data loss due to limitations in rotation of the mounting stage. Most current approaches for structure determination improve cryo-ET resolution either by some form of sub-tomogram averaging or template matching, respectively precluding detection of shapes that vary across objects or are a priori unknown. Various macromolecular structures possess polyhedral structure. We propose a classification method for polyhedral shapes from incomplete individual cryo-ET reconstructions, based on topological features of an extracted polyhedral graph (PG).ResultsWe outline a pipeline for extracting PG from 3-D cryo-ET reconstructions. For classification, we construct a reference library of regular polyhedra. Using geometric simulation, we construct a non-parametric estimate of the distribution of possible incomplete PGs. In studies with simulated data, a Bayes classifier constructed using these distributions has an average test set misclassification error of < 5 % with upto 30 % of the object missing, suggesting accurate polyhedral shape classification is possible from individual incomplete cryo-ET reconstructions. We also demonstrate how the method can be made robust to mis-specification of the PG using an SVM based classifier. The methodology is applied to cryo-ET reconstructions of 30 micro-compartments isolated from E. coli bacteria.ConclusionsThe predicted shapes aren’t unique, but all belong to the non-symmetric Johnson solid family, illustrating the potential of this approach to study variation in polyhedral macromolecular structures.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-016-1107-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Symmetry breaking and structural polymorphism in a bacterial microcompartment shell protein for choline utilization

“…Those have proven to assemble with high levels of order, even obeying icosahedral symmetry, with examples including a beta-carboxysome shell, a GRM2 microcompartment shell, and a shell from a microcompartment of unknown function, 15,30,31 but native forms of these MCPs likely diverge in important ways. Unlike their more symmetrical carboxysome counterparts, other native microcompartments have been found to have polymorphic structures 52,53 (Figure 1e). These include several MCP types, such as Pdu, Eut, and Cut.…”

Structural Analysis of Human Fascin-1: Essential Protein for Actin Filaments Bundling

“…The uniformly decorated 3800 segments were used to generate a 3D reconstruction of fascin-decorated F-actin. For electron tomography, the collected 60 projections of tilt series were aligned based on the fiducial markers (5 nm gold nanoparticles) and reconstructed through Radon transform with cone beam geometry using least squares based filtered back-projection in the IMOD etomo module (IMOD software package) [ 19 , 20 ]. The resulting 3D density map was displayed and examined using UCSF Chimera software [ 21 ].…”