Client or Volunteer? Understanding Neoliberalism and Neocolonialism Within International Volunteer Health Work

Abstract

As international volunteer health work increases globally, research pertaining to the social organizations that coordinate the volunteer experience in the Global South has severely lagged. The purpose of this ethnographic study was to critically examine the social organizations within Canadian NGOs in the provision of health work in Tanzania. Multiple, concurrent data collection methods, including text analysis, participant observation and in-depth interviews were utilized. Data collection occurred in Tanzania and Canada. Neoliberalism and neocolonialism were pervasive in international volunteer health work. In this study, the social relations—“volunteer as client,” “experience as commodity,” and “free market evaluation”—coordinated the volunteer experience, whereby the volunteers became “the client” over the local community and resulting in an asymmetrical relationship. These findings illuminate the need to generate additional awareness and response related to social inequities embedded in international volunteer health work.

Ethical Dilemmas in Global Plastic Surgery: Divergent Perspectives of Local and Visiting Surgeons

“…7,9 Historical colonial legacies affect current humanitarian efforts to provide more equitable access to surgical care. 5,10,11…”

Unpaid Work in Marine Science: A Snapshot of the Early-Career Job Market

“…In voluntourism, the participant pays a fee for an organised volunteering or internship opportunity, often in locations seen as "exotic" by the Eurocentric world. Such arrangements are often dictated by neoliberal market laws, where the intern is a demanding client rather than a worker (e.g., Wearing et al, 2005;Lyons et al, 2012;St-Amant et al, 2018), and can perpetuate neocolonialist relations (e.g., Mahrouse, 2012;Pastran, 2014;St-Amant et al, 2018). Yet, they can be beneficial when practiced responsibly (Palacios, 2010;Coghlan and Gooch, 2011;McGehee, 2014).…”

Preparation for nursing student placements abroad and in Canada's northern communities: a secondary analysis

“…My research reinforces that students require proper preparation to expose and break down these unbalanced power dynamics. Preparation that utilizes a reflexive process consisting of positionality and a post-colonial lens may shape the students' understanding in context to surrounding historical power and domination (Tiessen, 2018;St-Amant et al, 2018).…”

“…The findings from my thesis research also contributed to limited research that addresses pre-departure training. Despite the nursing profession's endorsement of service-learning experiences, there is limited research about specific pre-departure training in the nursing discipline (St-Amant et al, 2018). This absence of literature represents a significant gap that needs to be addressed.…”