Climate and conspecific density inform phenotypic forecasting of juvenile Pacific salmon body size

Abstract

1. Predicting effects of climate on fitness-linked phenotypic traits, such as body size, is important for the management and conservation of species in the face of global change. During sensitive life stages, small changes in mean trait values can have large effects on survival and population productivity.2. The transition from freshwater to saltwater by migrating anadromous fishes such as Pacific salmon (genus Oncorhynchus) is a critical life history transition, where survival is mediated by the size of migrating individuals. For salmon that spend extended periods rearing in freshwater, the size at ocean entry (i.e., smolt length) may be sensitive to changes in freshwater conditions shaped by biotic and abiotic factors, yet long-term phenotypic time series for exploring these responses are rare.3. We reconstructed a four-decade time series of smolt length from archives of returning adult scales to quantify population-specific responses to climate and conspecific density in a small watershed. 4. Dynamic linear modeling found that the relationship between a proxy for cohort density and smolt length at ocean entry was consistently negative, suggestive of competition. In contrast, there was a positive, yet dynamic, relationship between a proxy for density of emerging fry during the second summer of growth and smolt length.5. The effect of temperature on smolt length was not consistent between two populations of sockeye salmon O. nerka that likely use distinct habitats within the watershed. A positive relationship between smolt length and temperature was only detected for the less abundant, early returning population.6. Predictions of smolt length showed variable responses under scenarios of increasing temperature and high and low densities of conspecifics. Collectively, these results reveal population-specific responses to temperature and density, suggesting that local habitat conditions may filter larger-scale climate drivers.

Shrinking body size and climate warming: Many freshwater salmonids do not follow the rule

“…In contrast, a wide variety of studies on marine and anadromous species have overwhelmingly called attention to declining body size over time (Daufresne et al, 2009; Oke et al, 2020; Ulaski et al, 2021; van Rijn et al, 2017). Of those studies that specifically tested for temporal and spatial trends in body size changes with warming temperatures, about half were heavily focused on salmon in the northeast Pacific and these consistently found anadromous salmon species were migrating to the ocean earlier and attaining smaller sizes overall (Cline et al, 2019; Lewis et al, 2015; McPhee et al, 2016; Ohlberger, 2013; Oke et al, 2020).…”