Clinical Appropriateness of Telehealth: A Qualitative Study of Endocrinologists’ Perspectives

Abstract

Background Outpatient endocrinology care delivered by telehealth is likely to remain common post-pandemic. There is little data to guide endocrinologists’ judgments of clinical appropriateness (safety and effectiveness) for telehealth by synchronous video. We examined how, in the absence of guidelines, endocrinologists determine clinical appropriateness for telehealth, and we identified their strategies to navigate barriers to safe and effective use. Methods We conducted qualitative, semi-structured interviews with 26 purposively selected US endocrinologists. We used a directed content analysis to characterize participant perceptions of which patients and situations were clinically appropriate for telehealth, and to identify adaptations they made to accommodate telehealth visits. Results Endocrinologists’ perspectives about appropriateness for telehealth were influenced by clinical considerations, non-clinical patient factors, and the type and timing of the visit. These factors were weighed differently across individual participants according to their risk tolerance, values related to the physical exam and patient relationships, and impressions of patient capabilities and preferences. Some participants made practice adaptations that increased their comfort offering telehealth to a wider swath of patients. Conclusions Endocrinologists’ judgments about clinical appropriateness of telehealth for different patient situations varied widely across participants. The risk of such divergent approaches to determining appropriateness is unintended and clinically unwarranted variation in use of telehealth, compromising quality of care. Expert consensus is needed to guide endocrinologists now, along with studies to anchor future evidence-based guidelines for determining clinical appropriateness of telehealth in endocrinology.

Specialist Perspectives on Delivering High-Quality Telemedicine for Diabetes: A Mixed Methods Survey Study

“…However, use of telemedicine to overcome barriers to face-to-face care was perceived as a major benefit. These findings are consistent with prior work in which endocrinology providers report that telemedicine may be less effective for patients with high medical complexity or concerns for nonadherence but is most useful for established patients and those who face obstacles to accessing face-to-face care [ 20 ]. This specifically includes patients with geographic or transportation barriers, those who have comorbidities including mental health and conditions that limit mobility, as well as other factors such as work or caregiving responsibilities or immunocompromised states.…”

Identification and Management of Thyroid Dysfunction Using At-Home Sample Collection and Telehealth Services: Retrospective Analysis of Real-World Data

“…Measurement of TSH is an effective first step in assessment of thyroid function in most patients [ 18 ], and although limitations exist, many aspects of the physical examination can be conducted via telehealth with the assistance of the patient such as visualization of the thyroid, eyes, skin, and assessment for tremor [ 5 , 12 ]. Overall, paired with laboratory testing and referral to in-person follow-up procedures for conditions needing specialized attention, telemedicine is becoming a more acceptable option for thyroid care [ 5 , 6 , 19 ]. This may be particularly true for routine monitoring of thyroid conditions such as hypothyroidism and appointments for prescription refills or dose adjustments where diagnostic testing beyond laboratory values is not necessarily indicated.…”

Teleconsultation Landscape of Class A Tertiary General Hospitals in China: Insights from a National Survey (Preprint)

“…From the aspect of hospital, factors influencing the service volume at each hospital include available funding, management competency, and the number of professional staff [19] . Some doctors think that medical safety can't be guaranteed because physical examinations can't be done in telemedicine [34] , and they are concerned that personal connection through telehealth was inferior to office visits [12,35] . Our findings indicate that most hospitals in China primarily employ text-image teleconsultations, potentially proving insufficient for managing complex patient conditions.…”