Zika virus (ZIKV) is a mosquito-transmitted flavivirus and was first linked to congenital microcephaly due to a large outbreak in Northeastern Brazil. Although the ZIKV epidemic is now in decline, pregnancies in large parts of the Americas remain at risk due to ongoing transmission and the potential for new outbreaks. This review presents why Zika virus is still a complex and worrisome public health problem with an expanding spectrum of birth defects and why ZIKV and related viruses may evade the immune response to injure the fetus. Recent reports indicate that the spectrum of fetal brain and other anomalies associated with ZIKV exposure is broader and more complex than microcephaly alone and includes subtle fetal brain and ocular injuries; thus, the ability to prenatally diagnose fetal injury associated with ZIKV infection remains limited. New studies indicate that ZIKV imparts disproportionate effects on fetal growth with an unusual femur-sparing profile, potentially providing a new approach to identify viral injury to the fetus. Studies to determine the limitations of prenatal and postnatal testing for detection of ZIKV-associated birth defects and long-term neurocognitive deficits are needed to better guide counseling for women with a possible infectious exposure. It is also imperative that we investigate why ZIKV is so adept at infecting the placenta and the fetal brain to better predict other viruses with similar capabilities that may give rise to new epidemics. The efficiency with which ZIKV evades the early immune response to enable infection of the mother, placenta and fetus is likely critical for understanding why the infection may either be fulminant or limited. Furthermore, studies suggest that several emerging and related viruses may also cause birth defects, including West Nile virus, which is endemic in many parts of the United States. With mosquito-borne diseases increasing worldwide, there remains an urgent need to better understand the pathogenesis of ZIKV and related viruses to protect pregnancies and child health.