Clinical Validation of Novel Digital Measures: Statistical Methods for Reliability Evaluation

Abstract

<b><i>Background:</i></b> Assessment of reliability is one of the key components of the validation process designed to demonstrate that a novel clinical measure assessed by a digital health technology tool is fit-for-purpose in clinical research, care, and decision-making. Reliability assessment contributes to characterization of the signal-to-noise ratio and measurement error and is the first indicator of potential usefulness of the proposed clinical measure. <b><i>Summary:</i></b> Methodologies for reliability analyses are scattered across literature on validation of PROs, wet biomarkers, etc., yet are equally useful for digital clinical measures. We review a general modeling framework and statistical metrics typically used for reliability assessments as part of the clinical validation. We also present methods for the assessment of agreement and measurement error, alongside modified approaches for categorical measures. We illustrate the discussed techniques using physical activity data from a wearable device with an accelerometer sensor collected in clinical trial participants. <b><i>Key Messages:</i></b> This paper provides statisticians and data scientists, involved in development and validation of novel digital clinical measures, an overview of the statistical methodologies and analytical tools for reliability assessment.