Clinicians’ experiences on patients’ demands and shared decision making in Finnish specialized mental health care

Abstract

Purpose: Psychiatric patients' awareness of treatments options and their possibilities to influence their care has increased. For the clinicians, the management of evidence-based care, as well as organizational and resource aspects, set different goals for the clinical encounter. In this article we are focusing on the clinicians' experiences and ask: How do the clinicians view situations in which there is a conflict between patients' individual needs and goals and other aspects in decision-making? Materials and methods: We implemented a qualitative study of 13 thematic semi-structured interviews with clinicians working in psychiatry. We used discourse analysis to investigate how the clinician view the doctor-patient interaction. Results: We identified three discources which were termed the medical standpoint, the psychodynamic standpoint and the standpoint of the patient's experience. Conclusions: In their talk, the clinicians use the three discources to make sense of the diverse expectations from both the patient and the mental health care system. The three discources also reflect different aspects in psychiatric treatment cultures, such as evidence-based medicine, the ideal of patientcenteredness, therapeutic interaction and organizational requirements.

Quality of mental health services and rights of people receiving treatment in inpatient services in Finland: a cross-sectional observational survey with the WHO QualityRights Tool Kit

“…There is also room for improvement in service users’ preferences regarding treatment, informed consent, and facilities (standard score 2.4/3). A recent interview study among Finnish clinicians working in psychiatric care concluded that there seems to be a shift from paternalistic treatment decisions towards shared decision making (SDM) and patient-centered care [ 50 ]. From the viewpoints of service users and their families, these improvements are still modest [ 51 , 52 ].…”