Cluster policies of large cities in Russia and Kazakhstan

Abstract

Relevance. Faced with globalization challenges, large modern cities need to develop their competitive advantages. One source of such advantages is clustering of urban economy. Questions dealing with cluster-based policies and classification of clusters operating on the regional and national levels have attracted much scholarly attention while there is still a research gap regarding urban cluster policies and comparison of city-based clusters. Research objective. The purpose of this study is to analyze the legal framework of cluster policies in Russia and Kazakhstan and to describe the criteria for classification and comparison of city-based clusters. Data and methods. The study used methods of systemic and comparative analysis, formalized methods of analysis of regulatory acts. The selected criteria are universal and can be used for cluster analysis in different countries. We considered strategies for socioeconomic development of large cities in Russia and Kazakhstan from the official websites of city administrations as well as the regulatory acts of specific cities. Results. In both countries, clusters play a significant role in the development strategies of territories. The Russian and Kazakh governments take similar measures to support cluster initiatives. The regulatory legal acts of both countries emphasize the allocation of subsidies and co-financing of regional programs and R&D in clusters. The process of cluster creation in Russia started later than in Kazakhstan but was also more intensive. A popular specialization for clusters in both countries is information technologies and communications, which corresponds to the goals set by the national governments. Conclusions. In both countries, the number of clusters in large cities is increasing annually. Typically, clusters have 11-50 participants. In both countries, there are clusters of different specialization. Strategies for socioeconomic development serve as the main documents for devising cluster policies of cities. The practical significance of the study is that it proposes an approach to classification and comparison of clusters that can be used in further analysis and for identification of cluster policy priorities.

Clusters in Business: A Review of Successful International Models, Factors and Characteristics

“…In addition, the study of Turgel et al (2020), with the aim of analyzing the legal framework of innovation cluster policies in Russia and Kazakhstan and describing the classification and comparison criteria of city-based clusters. The study uses methods of systemic and comparative analysis and formalized methods of analysis of normative acts.…”

Land use∖cover change and influencing factors inside the urban development boundary of different level cities: A case study in Hubei Province, China

“…Cities are divided into different levels according to the size of population, economic and social activities ( Armen, 1972 ; Turgel et al., 2020 ). In China, cities are managed according to the urban administrative level system of municipality directly under the central government, sub-provincial city, prefecture-level city, county-level city, and county, and there are differences in the allocation of resources and policies enjoyed by cities at different levels, which leads to the different of the development of different level cities; the most direct manifestation of these situations are differences in LUCC, which carries all human economic and social activities ( Zhang et al., 2019 , 2021 ).…”