Co-curricular engagement among engineering undergrads: do they have the time and motivation?

Abstract

Background Co-curricular activities are often touted as valuable STEM learning opportunities in higher education settings. Particularly in engineering, industry encourage and seek students with co-curricular experiences. However, many engineering undergraduates do not regularly participate in those experiences. Some researchers have suggested that the rigors of the curriculum leave little time for co-curriculars. Yet, little research has empirically examined the reality of the undergraduate students’ involvement in co-curriculars. Thus, as an initial study, we situated our study in a large public university to explore students’ motivations for co-curriculars. In this paper we report on our efforts to understand student perceptions about the value and costs of that involvement. We considered how undergraduate engineering students used their time and what motivated them to engage (or not) in co-curriculars using Expectancy-Value Theory (EVT). Students’ motivation was investigated with a quantitative research methodology and complemented by interview data. Results Results of our motivation survey show that students who participated in co-curriculars perceived less cost than those who never participated. We also found that the achievement values of co-curriculars does not necessarily motivate student involvement. Interview data were used to further interpret quantitative data results. Conclusions In the context of study findings and existent literature, we discuss several implications for future research and practice. First, we argue for a more granular investigation of student time use and its impact on co-curricular participation. Second, despite the potential for high impact outcomes, students who have never participated perceived high cost for co-curricular engagement. Those perceptions may aggravate inequitable engagement of student populations, including historically marginalized populations in the STEM field. Third, students do not necessarily associate co-curricular experiences with the types of achievement values and learning that institutions, alumni, and industry might consider most important. Thus, to build and support co-curricular programs that provide the holistic educational experiences and learning that are anticipated, research that supports design of co-curricular programs and policies to improve engagement and persistence in those programs for all students is necessary.

Patterns in assignment submission times: Analysis of factors contributing to undergraduate students’ commitment to core-curriculum related course

“…This task may seem challenging to students because it requires consistent effort and discipline over an extended period. Additionally, students may face difficulties in finding the time and motivation to regularly engage in physical activity, especially if they have other commitments or responsibilities [ [38] , [39] , [40] ]. As a result, some students may struggle to complete the project(s) on time.…”

Examining the Setting of Significant Learning Events during the Engineering School-to-Work Transition

“…These kinds of experiences likely provide some of the emergent learning experiences that participants found noteworthy during their school-to-work transition and may therefore facilitate the development of skills that ease the transition. At the same time, however, non-traditional and underrepresented students (e.g., low SES) often face barriers to participating in these activities that others might not [39,40]. For instance, many students work part-time jobs or take care of families while they earn their degrees.…”

El aprendizaje basado en alumni, una nueva metodología de enseñanza

“…En este último caso implicará tiempo de dedicación por parte de los estudiantes. Algunos estudios constatan que los planes de formación actual, los currículos educativos no contemplan tiempo para los estudiantes para que mejoren sus competencias a través de actividades co-curriculares (Olewnik et al, 2023).…”