A strain of Lactobacillus bulgaricus has been shown to require an unidentified growth factor present in a variety of natural materials (Williams et al., 1949).This has been called the L. bulgaricus factor and is conveniently referred to as LBF. LBF has been shown to exist in natural materials in three to five forms all interchangeable for growth of the organism (Rasmussen et al., 1950). Two reports Brown et al., 1950) have indicated that high amounts of calcium pantothenate will replace the unidentified LBF and that at least two forms of LBF contain bound pantothenate. This paper reports experiments extending the paper chromatography studies and presents evidence for the existence of at least seven separate entities in crude materials. The location of pantothenate on paper strips, the activity of certain of the forms of LBF for other organisms, and the chromatographic behavior of concentrates from different sources are also reported. A concentrate of coenzyme A was found to yield three forms of LBF after enzymatic digestion.
EXPERIMENTAL METHODSThe general chromatographic procedures are similar to the bioautographic techniques described and used by Eigen (1949, 1950). These techniques are well suited for demonstrating the existence of interchangeable or alternative growth factors. Bacillus megatherium, B-938, culture filtrate was obtained through the kindness of Dr. J. C. Lewis, Western Regional Laboratories, Albany, California. This material contained 380 LBF units per ml by the tube assay method (Williams et al., 1949), and had a potency of 20 units per mg. The purified concentrate from this source had a potency of 4,000 units per mg and was prepared by charcoal adsorption and elution with n-butanol, followed by chromatography on a charcoal column using n-butanol as a developing solvent. LBF produced by Ashbya gossypii, NRRL 1056, was obtained by water extraction of the dried whole culture grown aerobically and contained 525 units per ml. The concentrate prepared from this organism had a potency of 1,500 units per mg and was prepared by a method similar to that used for the concentrate from B. megatherium culture filtrate.From 1.75 to 21 LBF units contained in 0.01 to 0.1 ml were spotted or spread 1 Published with the approval of the directors of the Experiment Station as paper no. 369 of the Journal Series.