Cognitive Biases in Orthopaedic Surgery

Abstract

Introduction: Cognitive biases are known to affect all aspects of human decision-making and reasoning. Examples include misjudgment of probability, preferential attention to evidence that confirms one's beliefs, and preference for certainty. It is not known whether cognitive biases influence orthopaedic surgeon decision-making. This study measured the influence of a few cognitive biases on orthopaedic decision-making in hypothetical vignettes. The questions we addressed were as follows: Do orthopaedic surgeons display the cognitive biases of base rate neglect and confirmation bias in hypothetical vignettes? Can anchoring and framing biases be demonstrated? Methods: One hundred ninety-six orthopaedic surgeons completed a survey consisting of three vignettes evaluating base rate neglect, five evaluating confirmation bias, and two separate vignettes each randomly exposing half of the group to different anchors and frames. Results: For the three vignettes evaluating base rate neglect, 43% (84 of 196) chose answers consistent with base rate neglect in vignette 1, 88% (173 of 196) in vignette 2, and 35% (69 of 196) in vignette 3. Regarding confirmation bias, 51% (100 of 196) chose an answer consistent with confirmation bias for vignette 1, 11% (22 of 196) for vignette 2, 22% (43 of 196) for vignette 3, 22% (44 of 196) for vignette 4, and 29% (56 of 196) for vignette 5. There was a measurable anchoring heuristic (56% versus 34%; a difference of 22%) and framing effect (77% versus 61%; a difference of 16%). Conclusion: The influence of cognitive biases can be documented in patient vignettes presented to orthopaedic surgeons. Strategies can anticipate cognitive bias and develop practice debiasing strategies to limit potential error.

Author Reply to “Regarding ‘Subacromial Decompression in Patients With Shoulder Impingement With an Intact Rotator Cuff: An Expert Consensus Statement Using the Modified Delphi Technique Comparing North American to European Shoulder Surgeons’”

“…7 Cognitive biases are well known to influence decision-making. Recently, Janssen et al 17 reported that 50% of orthopaedic surgeons are prone to commit confirmation bias. Myside bias is another very common type of cognitive bias, and surgeons tend to prefer to process information that confirms their own previous beliefs, opinions, and attitudes.…”

Distal Biceps Tendon Rupture Videos on YouTube: An Analysis of Video Content and Quality

“…24 In this context, cognitive bias (in particular the anchoring effect) can impact decision making for patients. 25 Similar to what is observed in patients with rotator cuff tears (the idea that the patient has a "tear" and that "it needs to be fixed"), these misconceptions can be reinforced by online information sources. 26 Ultimately, the surgeon's role is to aid in reorienting or redirecting patients with misconceptions regarding their DBT injury or treatment options; however, this can be more difficult in the face of poor online information.…”

Surgeon Ratings of the Severity of Idiopathic Median Neuropathy at the Carpal Tunnel Are Not Influenced by Magnitude of Incapability

“…Outlier surgeons who offer surgery based on magnitude of incapability rather than severity of pathology may not adequately account for the nuances of diagnostic science and the complexities of the biopsychosocial paradigm of human illness. These possibilities suggest several lines of investigation: (1) The relative influence of symptom intensity and pathology severity on surgeon treatment recommendations in actual patient care settings, (2) the relative understanding and accounting for the nuances of diagnostic science in developing health strategies [3,19,36], (3) the effectiveness of health strategies developed to limit surgeon-to-surgeon variation based on relative credulity in the face of limited objective evidence and therefore low probability of notable pathology, and (4) the relative influence of nonspecific effects of treatment when symptoms/incapability far outweigh pathophysiology in the decision to offer and accept operative treatment (simulated surgery controlled trials).…”