Collaborative emergency preparedness and response to cross-institutional outbreaks of multidrug-resistant organisms: a scenario-based approach in two regions of the Netherlands

Abstract

BackgroundThe likelihood of large-scale outbreaks of multidrug-resistant organisms (MDRO) is growing. MDRO outbreaks can affect a wide range of healthcare institutions. Control of such outbreaks requires structured collaboration between professionals from all involved healthcare institutions, but guidelines for cross-institutional procedures are, however, often missing. Literature indicates that such multi-actor collaboration is most promising when effective network brokers are present, and when the collaborative actors have clarity about the different roles and responsibilities in the outbreak response network, including collaborative structures and coordination roles. Studying these factors in an imaginary MDRO outbreak scenario, we gained insights into the expectations that health professionals in the Netherlands have in regard to the procedures required to best respond to any future cross-institutional MDRO outbreaks.MethodsFor exploration purpose, a focus group discussion with ten healthcare professionals was held. Subsequently, an online-survey was conducted among 56 healthcare professionals in two Dutch regions. The survey data was analysed using social network analyses (clique analysis and centrality analysis), which provided insights into the collaborative structures and potential brokers in the outbreak response networks. Additionally, respondents were asked which healthcare institutions and which professions they would prefer as coordinating actors in the collaborative network.ResultsOur results show a relatively high level of perceived clarity about the roles and responsibilities that healthcare professionals have during a joint outbreak response. The regional outbreak response networks which were studied appeared inclusive and integrated, with many overlapping groups of fully-connected healthcare actors. Social network analyses resulted in the identification of several central actors from different healthcare institutions with the potential to take on a brokerage role in the collaboration. Actors in the outbreak response networks also showed to prefer several healthcare professionals to take on the coordination roles.ConclusionExpected collaborative structures during an imaginary regional MDRO outbreak response are relatively dense and integrated. In regard to the coordination of an MDRO outbreak response, based on both the network analysis results and the preferred coordination roles, our findings support a governance structure with several healthcare institutions involved in responding to future cross-institutional MDRO outbreaks.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12889-018-6376-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Network of Networks: Preliminary Lessons from the Antwerp Port Authority on Crisis Management and Network Governance to Deal with the COVID‐19 Pandemic

“…This calls for further investigation of various wicked problems as coevolutionary patterns of interaction between networks and organizations as separate from, yet part of, an environment external to these networks and organizations themselves (Alter 1990;Nowell, Hano, and Yang 2019). The empirical work on fire and emergency services by Berthod et al (2017), on health care by Nowell, Hano, and Yang (2019), and on public health and infectious disease outbreaks by Raab et al (2020), De Vries et al (2019), and Kenis et al (2019) illustrates both the theoretical relevance and practical value of an exogenous perspective on network of networks.…”

Two-dimensional PCR for detecting class 1, 2 and 3 integrons

“…The discovery of antibiotics provides a powerful weapon for clinical anti-infection treatment, but the wide use of antibiotics leads to antibiotic resistance and produces a large number of multiantibiotic resistant strains ( de Vries et al., 2019 ). Antibiotic resistance may accelerate mankind get into the post antibiotic era ( Mc Carlie et al., 2020 ).…”

Multistakeholder Participation, Collaboration, and Networking in Disaster Risk Reduction and Pandemic Management: Insights and Future Policy Framework

“…Multistakeholder partnership in health emergency response situations tends to be futile when concerns about the ownership of outcomes and differences in organizational working practices amalgamate (Ryu & Johansen, 2017). If the collaborative efforts or partners have transparency about the roles and responsibilities, then the public health emergency can be handled more effectively within a short duration (de Vries et al, 2019). When multistakeholder participation is attempted in addressing earlier pandemics in the Asian region, issues such as resource limitation, unethical priority setting, and less confidence in the adopted surveillance technology inhibited effective pandemic preparedness (Bennett & Carney, 2011).…”