“…However, Liu et al (2004) performed simulations on the formation of fully collapsed SWCNTs with the atomic scale finite element method, and proposed that for armchair SWCNTs, collapse occurs for the critical radius (for n=30) is R max 2.06 nm, which is also different from the aforementioned results. In fact, this value of critical radius of 2.06 nm was verified by TEM observations, which demonstrated that there exists a collapsed SWCNT of 2.5 nm in radius (Xiao, et al, 2007). In spite of the above cited studies on the collapse of CNTs, there are hitherto no analytical solution for the collapse problem of CNTs, which involves large deformation and strong geometric nonlinearity.…”