While the industry has many recommendations on fishing operations and setups, a process of the selection for overshots, and a streamline when similar fish or wellbore conditions has not been discussed before. This paper will review a challenging case history well, with multiple fishes of the same type, and the lessons learned on selections with varying wellbore conditions. Taking into measure was the learnings from the post well review, and the creation of a flowchart to better optimize the selection of fishing Bottom Hole Assembly's (BHA). This incorporated the coordination of charts’ creation with the service provider, ensured a robust process with multiple choices and supportive reasoning for selection. The well primarily discussed in this paper, was a horizontal well in a tight gas field. The knowledge gained from the multiple fishes in the case study horizontal well, streamlined future choices in BHA selections for similar fishes. As an operator, having the flowchart encourages more discussion with the service company, and supports the engineers in planning operations.