It is shown that if P is a weak * -continuous projection on a JBW * -triple A with predual A * , such that the range P A of P is an atomic subtriple with finite-dimensional Cartan-factors, and P is the sum of coordinate projections with respect to a standard grid of P A, then P is contractive if and only if it commutes with all inner derivations of P A. This provides characterizations of 1-complemented elements in a large class of subspaces of A * in terms of commutation relations.Mathematics Subject Classification (2010). Primary 17C65; Secondary 47D27.