A collision tumor is an infrequent phenomenon characterized by the presence of 2 histologically distinct tumor types (either benign or malignant) occurring within the same specific anatomical site. We describe a rare case of co-occurrence of basal cell carcinoma and atypical fibroxanthoma presenting as a single lesion on the scalp in a 76-year-old man. The lesion was clinically suspicious for basal cell carcinoma and biopsied. Histologic examination showed 2 distinct tumors, one with basaloid cells and the other one with pleomorphic spindle cells colliding and growing together. Immunohistochemical stains were crucial in establishing the diagnosis. This presentation is exceedingly rare and requires additional evaluation for diagnosis.