Colonial Traditions, Co‐optations, and Mi'kmaq Legal Consciousness

Abstract

In 1996 a provincial court was established at Eskasoni Mi'kmaq Community in Nova Scotia, Canada, in response to overwhelming evidence confirming the failures of the Canadian legal system to provide justice for Indigenous peoples, and as a specific recommendation of the Royal Commission on the Donald Marshall, Jr., Prosecution. Marshall, a Mi'kmaq wrongfully convicted of murder, served eleven years of a life sentence before proving his innocence. The importation of provincial legal culture into an Indigenous community creates tensions and contradictions surrounding the legitimacy, authenticity, and efficacy of Indigenous laws. The ontological conflicts that arise from the imposition of a justice system integrally linked with colonization, criminalization, and assimilation cannot be resolved through indigenization of court staff and administrative conveniences. The Mi'kmaq continue to assert their laws and articulate their legal consciousness against the co‐optation of dominant system, with mixed results.

After Hegemony: The Varieties of Legal Consciousness Research

“…, to cock fighting (Young, 2014), to conservation (Pieraccini and Cardwell, 2016), to fat acceptance (Kirkland, 2008), to housing occupation (Cowan et al, 2018), to indigeneity (McMillan, 2011), to medicine (Halliday et al, 2014;Picton-Howell, 2018); to migration (Abrego, 2008(Abrego, & 2011Gehring, 2013;Schwenken, 2013), to ombudsmen (Gill & Creutzfeldt, 2017), to sexualities (Oswald & Kuvalanka, 2008;Harding, 2011;Knauer, 2012;Hull, 2016), to sex work (Boittin, 2013), to the sharing economy (Morgan and Kuch, 2016).…”

Hopi Tradition as Jurisdiction: On the Potentializing Limits of Hopi Sovereignty

“…In many respects, my approach here thus echoes the analyses L. Jane McMillan (2011, in this symposium) provides in her consideration of Mi'kmaq legal consciousness about the Canadian provincial court recently established in their largest community.…”

Building the Aboriginal Conference Settlement Suite: Hope and Realism in Law as a Tool for Social Change

“…In contrast to the United States, which has kept tribal law institutionally separate from the conventional or mainstream legal system (Goldberg 1997;Washburn 2017), Canada has been attempting to incorporate "culturally appropriate" justice programs into Canadian criminal law (Evaluation Division of the Corporate Services Branch 2017, iii). Elsewhere I have discussed the history of these efforts (Goldbach 2015; see also Giokas 1993;Kwochka 1996;McMillan 2011). The shortened version is as follows.…”