Combatting corruption in Kazakhstan: A role for ethics commissioners?

Abstract

Summary Central Asian countries have, since gaining independence in 1991, suffered from endemic corruption as a legacy of their Soviet roots. There are multiple ways of tackling corruption ranging from preventative to control measures. One tool in this battery of measures is the use of codes of ethics enforced through ethics commissioners. Kazakhstan is attempting to take a lead role in driving public sector reforms in the Central Asian region but has achieved limited success in addressing the seemingly intractable problem of corruption. This paper offers a formative assessment of the impact of ethics commissioners on the problem. We find limited political commitment for the initiative, institutional weaknesses, and the absence of a problem solving approach by the Kazakhstani government.

Public Sector Strategies in Curbing Corruption: A Review of the Literature

“…In this empirical research carried out in Germany, it emerges that only ethical leadership has a positive effect on employees' organization-related attitudes. Consistently with this evidence, Janenova and Knox (2020) demonstrate how the introduction of specific ethics commissioners improves the benefits deriving from the adoption of the code of conduct in the context of Kazakhstan.…”

Fighting Corruption in the Public Sector by Implementation of Effective Internal Audit Function

“…The political instability and influence overgovernance mechanism has become a hindrance to nation development and is seen as an extreme disease in the public sector, resulting in distrust and denunciation of citizens on the public sector administration. Janenova & Knox (2020) condemns that in several instances investigation of unethical behaviour demonstrates reluctance of political leadership as such cases are a risk to the political career and attraction of media creates political divergence; thus state bodies interferes with such investigations.…”

“…Alleviating public sector corruption requires political will to implement strong and adequate regulations, policies and procedures which are followed by officials at all levels of public sector institutes, providing IAF the freedom to deliver unbiased opinion and valuable contribution to address public sector corruption. Janenova & Knox (2020) underlines political will as a key element to tackle corruption in the public sector and takes form as legal and regulatory framework, anti-corruption programmes and strategies to improve professionalism and ethical behaviour of politicians and civil servants. Nonetheless, sustainable mitigation of corruption requires robust governance mechanism with improved framework and capacity to timely detect, investigate and prosecute acts of fraud and corruption, and an enduring system to recover such embezzlement to the state.…”

More ethical, more innovative? The effects of ethical culture and ethical leadership on realized innovation

“…Although still limited, there is a growing interest and concern about ethical leadership in public organisations (Bashir & Hassan, 2019; Hassan, 2015; Janenova & Knox, 2019). Despite the persistence of unethical behaviour in public sectors of developed and developing countries alike, governments across the globe have implemented countless integrity management measures in order to create ethical cultures, while emphasizing ethical leadership and the tone at the top in promoting ethical conduct (e.g.…”